Survivor 41

Episode 12 – The Edit Bay

What is the edit telling us after Episode 12?

Photo: CBS

Hello all, welcome to the Edit Bay! This weekly feature takes a dive into the edit of the latest Survivor episode, analyzing the key stories, main characters, and top winner contenders.

While intended as a condensed version of Edgic, for this season, I will be including my ratings for each castaway at the end of the article.


It’s been a rollercoaster of a season, but it’s time now for the final Edit Bay before the Survivor 41 finale. This is one last chance to evaluate the edits of the remaining five players and how the latest episode helped or hindered their chances of winning.

This episode firmly established a couple of key points and reaffirmed a season-long storyline. The first point was regarding Ricard being The Big Threat. We’re told Ricard will win if he makes it to the Final Tribal Council, and so, the goal is to take him out. This point was reiterated throughout the latest episode, as Ricard saved himself with a clutch Immunity win. The question? Is Ricard on a Ben/Tony style push to the end? Or is he merely set up as an obstacle the eventual winner has to overcome?

The second point was the emergence of a Final 3 deal between Deshawn, Erika, and Xander. This was built off the back of a reward and saw the three players toying with the option of working together. There was a tepid agreement, with Deshawn and Erika commenting on it in confessionals throughout the episode. The question? Is this our real Final 3? Or is it just a smokescreen?

There is precedent for the real Final 3 to be set up near the end of the season. The one that came to mind for me was the deal between Jeremy, Spencer, and Tasha in Cambodia. That scene also came in Episode 12 and was established after a Reward challenge (that time between the Reward losers). Much like this latest scene, an alliance was broached, but there was still some editorial doubt due to the cautious confessionals of Spencer and Tasha. So it wouldn’t shock me if Deshawn, Erika, and Xander were the real Final 3.

Photo: CBS

The final point was the reaffirming of the Deshawn versus Erika narrative. As we’ve spoken about before, this connection has been present since the early pre-merge (technically since the premiere if you consider Erika’s concerns about Deshawn’s idol searching). Erika had previously wanted to make a move with Deshawn (to vote out Sydney), but Deshawn didn’t trust Erika because he saw her as a threat (but his attempt to throw a challenge and get her out failed).

In this episode, the pair again considered working together, with Erika saying they could finally make that move they had always talked about. Deshawn was more open to it than previously but still had reservations, which caused him to drop his “truth bomb” on Erika at Tribal. Erika batted the bomb back at Deshawn, countering his points and highlighting it as a reason they have never been able to fully trust and work with each other. Yet, both are still in the game heading into the finale, making this relationship the most established and long-term story of the season.

So those are our three big stories heading into the final episode. But what does it mean in terms of winner contenders? I will break down the remaining five-character edits below, placing them in order of most likely to least likely to win.


If you had told me at the merge episode that Erika would be my top contender heading into the finale, I’d have laughed at you—and asked how you got hold of Jeff Probst’s hourglass. But after the elimination of Tiffany and Evvie (my top two contenders) and the disintegration of the underdog Yase complex tribe theory, I had no choice but to reevaluate.

Rewatching the season with a renewed focus on the tribe I’d previously brushed off (Luvu), it became clear that the Erika and Deshawn connection was an essential part of the puzzle. It was a relationship subtly set up in the premiere, firmly established in Episode 4, and carried through to the fake-merge episodes. The foreshadowing and themes hinted at in those episodes have since come to fruition in the post-merge, leading to Erika & Deshawn being the most important pair left.

One of Erika’s main edit flaws is the lack of alliance content in the pre-merge. More often than not, a winner’s edit will feature an established bond early on, even if in passing. Erika not having that was a big reason I dismissed her edit earlier in the season. But it’s not as if Erika had zero relationships. She DID have a connection; as we’ve seen with Deshawn, it was just more of a rivalry than an alliance. Or, I suppose you could call it a pseudo-alliance.

The Erika and Deshawn relationship has been returned to time and time again throughout the season, and it’s one of the bigger stories heading into the finale. If the both of them ARE in the Final 3 together, then it makes perfect sense why the edit chose to highlight this relationship in Erika’s edit. There has been a narrative throughline with this relationship from beginning to end.


But why was Erika’s pre-merge edit so under-the-radar? That’s the other common criticism of Erika’s edit and, again, something that made me initially overlook her potential. However, as I said in previous write-ups, the Episode 4 edit showed this as purposeful. Erika explained her quiet, lion in lamb’s clothing gameplay, while Deshawn told us he didn’t “want to give her the opportunity to play the slow beginning game and then emerge at the end and take me out.”

There was editorial intention to portray Erika as a quiet player who took the slow approach and emerged in the endgame. We’ve seen this emergence in the past couple of episodes, with the edit giving her credit (or partial credit) for each of the previous three boots. She was credited for swaying Danny and implementing the split vote at the Shan boot. She was presented as the swing vote decision-maker at the Liana vote. And in this episode, she was the one pushing for Danny to go over Deshawn.

Don’t get me wrong, if Erika is the winner, I still believe the show could have given her a better edit, especially as she’d be the first woman to win since Season 34. But that is more about the quantity of content rather than quality, which we can often overlook. Erika might not have a bright, flashy, overexposed edit, but the content she does have follows a consistent narrative and theme.

Also, Erika is the only player left that hasn’t received any negative content or been undermined. Even in this episode, when Deshawn threw out his truth bomb, the edit portrayed this as a mistake on Deshawn’s part, while Erika was afforded the time for her rebuttal. She also gave her perspective on keeping Ricard around, explaining why it made sense for her game.

On top of that, this latest episode brought back the “can a woman still win Survivor?” theme, which was initially brought up by Evvie in the pre-merge. Erika tied this to the representation talk, stating, “It’s been a long time since a woman’s won. I want to see a woman win, ideally me.” Now, Survivor has toyed with these themes before and it still ended with a man winning. But surely one of these days it’s got to pay off?

Overall, Erika is now presented as a key decision-maker, fulfilling her foreshadowed trajectory of the lamb-to-lion, no longer a follower but the person making the decisions. Her season-long story with Deshawn is about to come to a climax in the finale, very likely at the Final Tribal or in the fire-making challenge. And, if I had to put a bet on it, my money would be on Erika coming out on top.


There is no doubt that Deshawn has had a rounded, complex edit. He’s had a substantial mix of strategic and personal content, offering his perspective on the game and topics beyond the game. We saw that again in this penultimate episode, as Deshawn opened up to his tribemates about his struggle with the Shan vote.

However, the issue with Deshawn’s edit is that he is undermined a lot and made to look reactive and impulsive. In this episode, he tried to cause a wedge between Erika and Heather. His initial talk with Erika at the water well went okay; he got what he desired out of the conversation. But his move at Tribal was thrown back in his face, with the tribe and even Jeff questioning his motivations. It made him look foolish, given that he didn’t get voted out, and made it look like Erika spared him.

There is some great irony in Erika saving Deshawn, given that back in Episode 4, Deshawn worried that Erika would emerge at the end to take him out. Was that intended as ironic foreshadowing all along? Will Erika actually be the one to help Deshawn get to the end? Or will Deshawn’s mistake here end up causing Erika to boot him in a self-fulfilling prophecy?

Photo: CBS

Now, we should consider a world where Deshawn’s attempt to separate Erika and Heather comes to fruition. One would expect it to be a lingering thought in Heather’s mind, at least. If that is the case, then perhaps the irony at play was on Erika in a sort of role reversal. Deshawn failed to take Erika out in the pre-merge, and now Erika failed to take out Deshawn, despite recognizing him as a bigger threat than Danny. It’s not a totally insane theory.

However, nothing has told us that Deshawn will get his way based on the edit throughout the season. His journey has been littered with botched moves and indecision. So, even if the finale does play up the tension between Erika and Heather, it’s hard to see it ultimately working out for Deshawn in the end.

So, why do I have Deshawn as my second contender? Well, if I’m sticking to my theory that Deshawn & Erika is the most important pairing in the season, then I have to believe the winner is one of them. I already jumped off one theory with the underdog Yase tribe earlier this season, so I can’t abandon ship again, not at this stage.


Ricard is the player I believe the edit wants us to think is the winner at this point. For the past couple of weeks, we’ve been told over and over how big of a threat Ricard is and how he’ll definitely win if he makes the Final 3. The first part of this episode was all about the other five players gearing up to boot Ricard because of his threat level. And, of course, Ricard saved himself with another Immunity win.

The weird thing about Ricard’s edit in this past episode, though, was a lack of perspective from the man himself. While we heard all the others talking up how much of a threat he is, we never really heard Ricard’s thoughts on this or how he planned to make it to the end. This is different from a Tony or a Ben, two other big threats that were public enemy number one in the endgame. We always heard from Tony and Ben about their next plans and how they would counter the incoming onslaught.

Meanwhile, Ricard didn’t receive a confessional until mid-way through the episode, and it focused on Danny potentially having an idol. His other confessional was about his worries about Deshawn linking up with Erika and Heather; therefore, he wanted Danny out over Deshawn. We heard his worries, but we didn’t hear what he intended to do to combat these worries.

Photo: CBS

Secondly, Ricard was shown to have the incorrect read a lot in this episode. He started by saying that Xander is a loyal and trustworthy player, as the edit cut to Xander plotting Ricard’s downfall. He felt pretty confident that Danny had an idol, which wasn’t the case. Plus, he didn’t get his way with the vote, instead acquiescing to Erika and her desire to take out Danny before Deshawn.

It’s those things that make me see Ricard more as the final obstacle rather than the winner. It reminds me of a Joe edit in a sense, often talked of as a threat but a lack of individual perspective on how he would get to the end. It feels like Ricard is the final boss that the eventual winner needs to take down, whether that is at Final 5 or the Final 4 fire-making challenge.

Could I be wrong? Certainly—it wouldn’t be the first time this season! Maybe Ricard continues his Immunity streak and Mike Holloway’s his way to the end. But even with Mike’s edit, I felt like he offered more of his perspective on the dynamics in the endgame. Ricard’s edit has always felt a bit secondary—second fiddle to Shan in the pre-merge, absent in the important merge episode, and simply presented as “the threat” in the penultimate episode.

That might sound rich coming from someone who has Erika as their top contender. But Erika’s quieter moments have an in-built editorial excuse of “playing the slow game and emerging at the end.” It’s a weak edit trick for sure, but it’s there and has been consistent. For me, Ricard’s narrative hasn’t had that consistency, and so, I have to go with my gut, which tells me Ricard isn’t making the Final 3.


Xander’s recent edit has changed my mind a little on his final destination. I’d felt that in recent weeks, Xander was heading for the “robbed fan-favorite” position. The lone wolf underdog that makes it close to the Final 3 but is pipped at the last minute. His underdog status combined with speckles of positivity just seemed to point in that direction. Now, I’m not so sure.

I say that because this episode subtly suggested that Xander isn’t as big of a threat as he believes. He told Danny that he kept Ricard around to be a shield. Xander believes that once Ricard is gone, he will become the number one target. Yet, Ricard won Immunity this episode, and not one person mentioned Xander. Even though he still has an idol, nobody brought up Xander as a potential target.

So could Xander make the Final Tribal Council and not win? I think so. If that’s the case, it could explain the large missing piece of Xander’s edit—personal content. I’ve said it throughout this season, but we never hear anything personal from Xander about who he is outside of the game. Every other player left has had personal moments; even Heather talked about her family at the marooning and had the confessional about her age.

Photo: CBS

Could this be because the edit didn’t want viewers getting too attached to Xander? He’s already a pretty popular player, so imagine how much more fanfare he’d have if people also had an emotional connection to him. If Xander had the underdog edit AND the personal content, then went on to lose at the FTC, there could be fan backlash. So keeping Xander at arm’s length would soften the blow.

Adding to that, Xander has had moments where he has been undermined. The pre-merge saw him out of the loop with the Yase women, including the scene where Tiffany mocked him over his idol blunder. And, much like Ricard, this episode saw him pushing for Danny to stay over Deshawn, but he didn’t get his way. Other than his trick with the fake idol, Xander hasn’t really had any standout moves or been presented as a key decision-maker. So I could most definitely see Xander making the end but not winning.


If Heather ends up winning this season, then we might as well tear up the Edgic rulebook and burn it in a fire pit. While she’s had some nice moments the past couple of weeks, shown as understanding and compassionate, Heather’s edit as a whole is severely lacking.

I said earlier that Edgic isn’t always about quantity, it’s about quality, but Heather’s edit has neither. In fact, I’m not sure if Heather has ever had a strategic confessional about her own game. She’s barely had any confessionals at all. This episode was one of her most visible, but it still didn’t offer a lot. Her first confessional about learning to understand people’s cultural differences felt more like a season-wide commentary (or a last-minute journey edit).

Photo: CBS

With that said, I’m not fully sure where Heather’s edit will end up. Your instinct might be to place has as a FTC goat. But it’s not as if the edit has hammered home that Heather is a terrible player or a bad person—we haven’t seen enough of her to form a proper opinion. And FTC goats of the past seem to have had more air-time than this. So first boot of the finale or even fire-making loser makes more sense in my mind.

At the very least, Heather now has a story heading into the finale. Deshawn dropping his truth bomb about how Erika doesn’t want to take Heather to the end should lead to something. You would expect Heather to at least briefly comment on this at the start of the next episode. It might even tie into Heather’s elimination.


For more information on how Edgic works and rating definitions read our Introduction to Edgic article.

Name EP 1 EP 2 EP 3 EP 4 EP 5 EP 6 EP 7 EP 8 EP 9 EP 10 EP 11 EP 12 EP 13 EP 14
Deshawn2Deshawn UTR2 OTTP4 UTR1 CP5 UTR1 MOR2 CPP4 CP3 CPM4 CPM4 CPM4 CPM5    
Xander2Xander MORP3 CP5 UTR1 UTRP1 MORN3 MOR3 CPP5 CP4 CP4 UTR1 CP3 MOR2    
Danny2Danny CP4 INV UTR1 MORP3 MOR2 CP3 MOR3 UTR2 MOR2 CP4 OTTP4 CP3    
Shan2Shan CP4 MOR2 CPP5 CP5 CPP5 CPM5 MOR3 CPN5 CPN4 CPP5        
Evvie2Evvie CPP4 CP5 UTR1 MORP2 MOR2 MOR3 MORP4 CPP4 CP3          
Naseer2Naseer MORM3 OTTP3 MOR2 UTRP2 MORP3 MOR2 UTR1 MORP3 OTT3          
Tiffany2Tiffany CPP4 OTTN5 MOR4 MORP2 MOR3 CP3 UTR2 MOR3            
Syd2Sydney MOR2 UTR2 MORN5 OTTN3 UTRP2 MOR2 MOR3              
Genie2Genie OTTP2 UTR1 UTR2 OTTM5 MOR4                  
JD2JD CPM5 UTR2 OTTM5 OTTN5                    
Brad2Brad OTTM2 OTTN3 OTT5                      
Voce2Voce MOR3 MOR4                        
Sara2Sara OTTP4                          
Abraham2Abraham MOR3                          

Written by

Martin Holmes

Martin is a freelance writer from England. He’s represented by Berlin Associates for comedy writing and writes about TV and entertainment, currently for TV Insider and Vulture, previously Digital Spy, ET Canada, and Yahoo. A finalist for the Shortlist Sitcom Search in 2012 for “Siblings,” Martin received his BA in English with Creative Writing from The University of Hull. Martin is the owner and editor-in-chief of Insider Survivor.

4 responses to “Episode 12 – The Edit Bay”

  1. Heather is winning they’re gonna show a montage of all her unaired strategic moments after she’s announced in the ultimate plot twist of the season

  2. If Ricard makes FTC, he wins, if he doesn’t, Erika wins. Ricard’s got a really tough road to get there. This has Erika win written all over it.

  3. Hi Martin, great writeup as usual! Just a note: you gave Erika a CP4, however you gave her the color corresponding to a CPP.

    Thank you for all your writeups this season, I’ve really enjoyed them!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The reCAPTCHA verification period has expired. Please reload the page.