Survivor 51

Christine & Gia’s Island Round-Up – Episode 8

Christine and Gia break down Episode 8.

CBS

Each week, Christine Pallon and Gia Worthy will round up the previous week of Survivor 51 as they list their top moments in various important categories. This includes the most essential information, the stand-out castaways, and the key moments from the week.

Here, Christine and Gia break down all the action from the latest episode.

Top 3 Moments

Carter is salty

Christine: This eventful episode saw Carter, who’s had a quiet past few weeks after his accidental mutiny, decide to take control with a new majority alliance. Fed up with players he views as messy and disloyal (cough Mike cough), Carter formed his Salt of the Earth Alliance, which includes himself, Lewis, Kilby, Cristian, Thien An, and Maggie. To further solidify Cristian in this group, Carter revealed his idol to him as a show of his own loyalty.

The Trouble with Doubles

Christine: The Double Duo twist is back! Or Tied Destinies if you’re cultured. Our pairs were Carter and Cristian, Mike and Maggie, Kristin and Kilby, Lewis and Sharonda, Devin and Jelly, and Eric and Thien An, and they all competed in a (very long) multi-part immunity challenge to determine which duo would be safe at a very dangerous tribal council. Sharonda and Lewis came out on top, leaving the rest of the duos vulnerable. Devin and Jelly, the odd ones out in this merge as the only members of their swap tribe left, made themselves easy targets by pairing up.

Jelly hoped to see Carter and Cristian out of the game, but the rest of the tribe was happy to make her and Devin the Mayors of Ponderosa after Brady abandoned his position to tend to his thumb. Carter gave Jelly and Devin a fake plan to vote Kristin and Kilby to avoid an idol play, but Sharonda revealed to her Helicopter Alliance allies that they weren’t as safe as they thought. Just before tribal, talk of idols, Cristian’s Extra Vote from his trip to Exile, and Shot in the Dark play abounded.

Devin and Jelly… Does Not Count

Gia: When the duos twist was announced, Jelly and Devin stood out as a clear target for anyone not working with them. While most other groups decided to work with someone outside of their alliance, they decided to go with their island bestie, a mistake to anyone without an idol… or Sharonda as an ally. Luckily for them, Jelly had both, and her fellow Helicopter Alliance member tipped her off that all of the votes were going to them. When it came time for the votes to be read, Jelly shocked everyone by playing her idol, one that only Devin and Sharonda knew about. One by one, the votes came in for Devin and Jelly… all negated, and no one thought to split the votes. Well, Devin and Jelly did, and Devin’s lone vote for Kristin and Kilby was enough to send them to Ponderosa. It just goes to show you that in a sea of twists and turns, sometimes the most iconic twist of all is a simple idol play. 

Advantage Watch

Idols

Gia: Jelly’s idol play saved her and her number one ally Devin this episode, but now only her Shot in the Dark can save her from this point forward (unless, of course, she finds another idol). Cristian’s Shot in the Dark saved both himself and Carter, meaning the latter didn’t have to play his idol as a protective measure. The only piece of the puzzle that remains unsolved is whether or not Sharonda has a full idol now that Kristin is out of the game. Presumably, we’ll get the answer in the next episode. 

Extra Vote

Christine: As part of his trip to Exile, Cristian lost his vote (BOO!) and was forced to earn it back (BOO!) by doing a silly little task (BOO!). He successfully got his vote back in the end and earned himself an Extra Vote in the process, which was only good for this tribal. Since he wanted to play his SITD, Cristian pawned the EV off to Eric at the last minute. Instead of using it to split the vote in case of an idol play or SITD hit, Eric stunned us all by pocketing the now-dead advantage. I look forward to hearing Eric’s reasoning on this choice post-game, because I’m still baffled by his decision!

Shot in the Dark

Christine: Kristin and Cristian both sacrificed their votes for a chance at safety, but unfortunately for Kristin and Kilby, Cristian and Carter were the only ones who had luck on their side this week. With Cristian’s successful SITD play, the duo negated the only vote cast against them and sent Kristin and Kilby to the jury with their single vote against.

Top 3 Contestants

Jelly

Christine: Jelly had a messy week when her duo with Devin nearly ended her game, but thanks to a perfectly played idol, she gets to stay in the game for at least another day. Jelly is actually very well-positioned in this merge, but pairing up with Devin made them too obviously an “easy” and “safe” vote, which is very tempting for an early merge vote during a dangerous twist where everyone is already playing scared. Jelly still has some life left, but it’s in her best interest to continue forging her own path away from Devin and not hesitate to let him go if she needs to. 

Lewis

Gia: Lewis may not have ultimately gotten his way this round, but he’s still one of the top contenders to win the whole game. He wisely partnered up with Sharonda this round, and that decision led to both of their safety when they won immunity together. He also rallied the votes against Jelly and Devin, showcasing his social capital among the remaining players. Yes, they should have planned to split the votes, but Lewis is so well insulated that I doubt this misstep will lead to his downfall. Faults and all, Lewis is playing an incredible game, and I look forward to seeing how he recovers next episode.

Sharonda

Gia: In my opinion, the only person left in the game with a better edit than Lewis is Sharonda. This episode solidified her winning potential for me, especially since one of the other players with strong winning potential (Kristin) is out. Not only did she win immunity and vote with the majority, but she also let Jelly know she needed to play her idol. What’s more, I have full confidence that the players will not be able to sniff out that it was Sharonda who spilled the beans. I don’t know if she actually ends up winning, or if she even makes it to finale night, but I’ll be rooting for her the entire way through. 

Fallen Comrades

Kristin

Christine: Kristin is a good player who just couldn’t manage her threat level, but in the end what took her out was some bad luck and a risky plan to pile votes on the obvious duo who just so happened to have an idol. I do think Kristin likely would’ve gone mid-merge anyway because of Maggie’s laser focus on her, but her time was certainly cut short by a mix of unfortunate factors. Kristin seems very at peace with her Survivor experience, and she certainly proved herself to be a worthy casting choice after all those years of applying.

Gia: Kristin went from winner contender to Mayor of Ponderosa in the blink of an eye, and quite frankly I do not think I’ll ever forgive the duos twist for this outcome. Kristin was the best of us, the epitome of a super fan turned contestant finally getting the chance to live out their Survivor dream. She is probably the closest we will get in the 50s to an “old-school” style player, which in my book is all the more reason to love her. I will miss her dearly as a player in this game, but I’m comforted that we still have her on the season as a member of the jury. If we can’t have her as a winner, at least she will make a fantastic Mayor of Ponderosa.

Kilby

Christine: Unlike Kristin, whose threat level was skyrocketing, Kilby really seemed to be in a social sweet spot where he could’ve made a very deep run in the game. He had a great recovery in this merge after his tie-vote shenanigans really could’ve made him a target, but he seemed very well positioned socially and had a lot of options moving forward. A superfan and nerd like Kilby knows luck is an inherent part of Survivor, and that sometimes that SITD is going to hit, and sometimes it won’t. I would’ve loved to see Kilby throw a vote here to give himself and Kristin some extra insurance (it would’ve been hilarious to see him force a tie for the second time), but I also understand why he didn’t. Risk is as much a part of Survivor as luck is, and unfortunately for Kilby and Kristin, the risk of a unanimous vote against Jelly and Devin is what ended their games. 

Gia: We lost not just one, but two super fans this round, and Kilby is the second half of this beloved duo. It’s never easy to see players I’m rooting for get eliminated, but watching super fans fall victim to new-school twists hurts the most. Kilby may not have accomplished his dream of winning the game, but I’d argue that he managed to achieve a lot of the super fan benchmarks. He made the merge and jury, was on the right side of multiple votes, and drove one of the more memorable tribal councils in recent history. Kilby has a lot to be proud of over the 15 days he played, and I hope he is. He may have come up short, but I hope he can still look back on his time in the game fondly.


Written by

Christine Pallon

Christine is a writer, musician, and lifelong Survivor nerd based out of Urbana, Illinois. When she’s not playing shows with her bands or working at her day job at a tech company, she spends her free time tweeting about bad horror movies, Kate Bush, and the filmography of Juliette Binoche. Christine writes Inside Survivor’s episode recaps for Survivor US.


Gia Worthy

Gia Worthy is a Massachusetts native and a lifelong fan of Survivor. When she's not helping to run the Survivor Diversity Campaign Twitter page, you can find her on her own Twitter, letting everyone know that Survivor: Marquesas and Fiji are criminally underrated.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


The reCAPTCHA verification period has expired. Please reload the page.