The Twisted Destinies twist was back for Survivor 51, which led to not one, but two people leaving the game. While it’s almost always sad to lose multiple players in a row, it’s also one step closer to knowing who will eventually win the season.
In episode 8, everyone was pissed off at Mike for being a blabbermouth and at Carter for creating the Salt alliance to control the game. The players were then told to divide into pairs: Carter and Cristian, Mike and Maggie, Kilby and Kristin, Jelly and Devin, Eric and Thien An, and Lewis and Sharonda.
Before the immunity challenge, Jeff Probst told the players that Brady had returned home to treat his injury, meaning he wouldn’t be part of the jury. Sharonda and Lewis won immunity, and the target seemed to be centered on Jelly and Devin. However, other pairs such as Carter/Cristian and Kristin/Kilby were also deemed threats.
At Tribal Council, Jelly played her idol for herself and Devin, which negated 8 votes. Cristian’s Shot in the Dark also protected him and Carter, and after Kristin’s SITD failed, with only one vote against them, it led to her and Kilby being eliminated from the game. Kristin and Kilby then became the first and second jurors of the season, respectively.
In their post-game interviews, both went into detail about their Survivor experience, unseen Tribal Council shenanigans, and much more. Here are some tidbits regarding their exit press revelations.
Speaking with Entertainment Weekly, Kristin revealed that she tried to use her Tethered Idol to get Sharonda or Lewis to give her either of their immunity necklaces (since Kristin’s TI could only protect Sharonda, and therefore Lewis). Maggie heard her proposal and told Sharonda not to do it, and Sharonda agreed she wouldn’t give her necklace to anyone. Kristin then went down the SITD route, which ultimately failed. Kristin was also asked if she was the player Jeff referenced as potentially replacing him in the future on Survivor 51. Kristin replied, ‘’You’re gonna have to ask Jeff that.’’
In an interview for Parade, Kristin went into more detail about her relationship with Maggie and why Maggie was so adamant about voting her out. She said that after Maggie told her she found her intimidating (which was shown on the episode), Kristin said her thoughts were, “‘Girl, come on! Let’s be so for real, because you are also an intimidating player, and we could just play together.’ I love an intimidating woman. That’s me. So yes, I knew that it was a thing for Maggie. I knew she was coming for me. And you know what? What can you do? You can know as much as possible.”
As to what she could’ve done to change her perception in the game, particularly about her threat level, Kristin added, ‘’I tried to reduce my threat level. I actually probably could have increased my threat level. ‘Maggie, you think I have an idol? I actually have four. Come at me. Do you want to play with me or what?'”
In addition, Kristin said she had two “number ones” in the game: Sharonda and Cristian. While Kristin doubted she would have gone to the end with Sharonda (as she’s not of the mindset of ‘’taking the best to the end’’ because she actually wanted to win), Kristin said she would’ve loved to have played with Sharonda for as long as it was possible.
Lastly, as to Mike’s threat we saw back on episode 7 about Kristin doing what he wanted or else she would be next, Kristin disclosed that it was a misunderstanding, and once she made Mike aware of how it came across, he profusely apologised to her, which rectified the situation.
As for Kilby, in interviews for The Exclusive with Sharon Tharp and Rob Has a Podcast (RHAP), he said he hadn’t known about Kristin’s Tethered Idol until they were on a boat ride after they were eliminated from the game. Kilby also added that, knowing how many people were truly behind getting rid of Kristin because of her threat level, he wouldn’t have paired up with her, since he ended up as collateral damage.
In the same RHAP interview, Kilby was asked if he had truly been down to go to rocks at the Tribal Council where Linnea was voted out, or if it was all a bluff. Kilby reiterated that he was 100% down on going to rocks.
Regarding his ambiguous friendship and alliance with Eric, Kilby was asked if he and Eric ever got on the same page again after Eric felt betrayed by him. Kilby explained that Eric said plenty about everything, and his actions didn’t come across to others the way he perceived them, which ultimately led Kilby to see Eric as a ‘scared player’ who gave him the ‘ick.’
Last but not least, in his interview with The Hollywood Reporter, Kilby said his actual number one ally was Thien An, as he opened up about his past and his upbringing below the poverty line, particularly to Thien An and Sharonda. This also brought them closer in the game and made them aware of how truly important Survivor was to him, as this was, in Kilby’s words, the thing that would’ve changed his life forever in multiple ways.
Written by