Survivor 44

Episode 4 – The Edit Bay (Shortened Edition)

What is the edit telling us after Episode 4?

Photo: CBS

Edit Bay this season is going to be a much shorter analysis due to spoilers. However, I will still assign ratings to each player, so readers can track the chart throughout the season. And I will highlight a few potential story arcs and important alliances. But there will be no discussion of potential winner edits.


Survivor 44 continues to place the majority of its focus on advantages and twists, with significant screen time spent on explaining the rules of new powers. This episode, in particular, felt the weight of that, especially with two challenges eating into the rest of the running time.

Sifting through all that, this episode centered on two similar stories, one from Carolyn and one from Josh. Both stories revolved around being the odd one out, which has been a consistent theme of Carolyn’s edit from the start. But both players had different perspectives on their positions despite coming together, in the end, to pull off a blindside.

Carolyn is someone who is aware of her position in her tribe. Despite working with Yam Yam recently, she still recognized where she stands on the totem pole. She did not appreciate being the decoy vote as she understood what that meant. “They don’t do a great job of making me feel like I’m in with them,” she said. “So why would I have any loyalty to them is how I feel right now.”

Photo: CBS

Compare that to Josh, who was also on the outs on Soka and yet wasn’t aware of his position. He started the episode by saying, “I’m in the perfect position where I’m in the middle between two different, opposing alliances that both trust me, and that makes me feel good.” But as we saw, the rest of his tribe immediately undermined him, with Heidi telling us that Josh was the next target.

It was fitting then that the unaware Josh ended up coming out on top in this episode due to the aware Carolyn clueing him in on which way the vote was going. So there was a cool little story arc across this episode hidden behind all the other nonsense.

As for the rest, the dynamics are still kind of threadbare. We saw Jaime join Soka and basically assume Josh’s position as the easy next vote. And on Ratu, Matthew extended an olive branch to Carson, sharing info to bring him on his side. But we don’t have a real sense of who the target would be on Ratu should they attend tribal any time soon.


Frannie & Matt (Pair) — Not as much focus on the potential showmance this week, but they were still named as a pair in the opening Soka scene.

Danny & Heidi (Pair) — Also clocked as a pair in the opening scene, Danny & Heidi also appear to be in a foursome with Frannie & Matt.

Carolyn, Carson, & Yam Yam (Alliance?) — This trio is now split up, but there is still a focus on their relationship. But it’s not as simple as a tight three wanting to ride things out. There is a lot of distrust between this trio. Obviously, we saw Carolyn and Yam Yam clash over the decoy vote situation, with Carolyn ultimately voting against Yam Yam’s wishes. And Carson was happy to throw Yam Yam under the bus to his new tribe, painting him as the one in charge.

Carson & Matthew (Pair?) — Matthew revealed the info about Jaime’s idol (the fake one) to Carson, hoping to forge a bond. Given that this was the only real scene we saw of Carson on Ratu, it would suggest this pairing is important to some degree. Although, it should be noted we didn’t hear Carson’s thoughts on Matthew.

Carolyn & Josh (Pair?) — Could these two become a powerful pair in the game? Hmm, perhaps. But the episode painted it more as an alliance of necessity, at least on Josh’s part. And for Carolyn, it seemed more about asserting herself.




Name EP 1 EP 2 EP 3 EP 4 EP 5 EP 6 EP 7 EP 8 EP 9 EP 10 EP 11 EP 12 EP 13 EP 14
Brandon2Brandon CPM5 MOR2 OTTP2 UTR2                    
Carolyn2Carolyn OTT3 OTT5 UTR2 CP5                    
Carson2Carson MORP3 CP5 MOR2 CP3                    
Danny2Danny UTR1 MOR3 CP5 MOR2                    
Frannie2Frannie MOR3 MORM3 CP3 MOR2                    
Heidi2Heidi MORP2 UTR1 CP4 UTR2                    
Jaime2Jaime OTT3 UTR1 OTT3 OTT4                    
Josh2Josh UTR1 INV MOR2 CPN5                    
Kane2Kane MOR3 MOR3 OTT2 INV                    
Lauren2Lauren CPN4 UTR2 UTR2 UTR1                    
Matt2Matt CP4 MORM3 MORN4 UTR1                    
Matthew2Matthew CPP5 CPP2 CP3 CP2                    
YamYam2Yam Yam MORP4 CP4 OTT2 OTTM5                    
Sarah2Sarah MOR3 MOR2 MOR3 MOR4                    
Claire2Claire UTR2 UTRN3 MORN5                      
Helen2Helen MOR3 MOR4                        
Maddy2Maddy MORN3                          
Bruce2Bruce UTRP2                          

Written by

Martin Holmes

Martin is a freelance writer from England. He’s represented by Berlin Associates for comedy writing and writes about TV and entertainment, currently for TV Insider and Vulture, previously Digital Spy, ET Canada, and Yahoo. A finalist for the Shortlist Sitcom Search in 2012 for “Siblings,” Martin received his BA in English with Creative Writing from The University of Hull. Martin is the owner and editor-in-chief of Insider Survivor.

2 responses to “Episode 4 – The Edit Bay (Shortened Edition)”

  1. You have Yam as OTTN5 but in orange…is that supposed to be red, or is his rating supposed to be OTTM5?

  2. I love ur edgic writing I just miss the longer ones, even though I think ur edit reading last season was mistake by the show edit, I still feel you and all of us always knew that there was something kinda wrong with Cassidy and Jesse edit, I think you are a great writer and observer of the show, and I know it probably takes a lot of your time, I appreciate ur effort on sharing all of this with us, thank you!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The reCAPTCHA verification period has expired. Please reload the page.