The Day 38 Club (11 – 9)

Ian Walker continues The Day 38 Club, ranking the last eliminated players from each season of Survivor.

The last person to leave the game, the person so close to the end they can taste the money, but has their opportunity to plead their case to the jury taken away at the very last moment. That person becomes ingrained in their respective season as the final recipient of “The Tribe Has Spoken” and earns a place in a very special group in Survivor history: The Day 38 Club.

With this list, I will rank all 32 current members of the Day 38 Club. When compiling the list, I took into account the strength of their game, character and the power of their story. Without further ado, the next three members of the Survivor Day 38 Club.

CydneySnuff11. Cydney Gillon (Survivor: Kaoh Rong)

From her keen sense of observation, easy-going personality and hilarious soundbites, Cydney Gillon was a supremely fun person to watch play Survivor. Encompassing the brains, brawn, and beauty that bore her season’s namesake, Cydney was able to use her chipper and laid-back demeanor to form strong relationships with almost everybody in the game and seemed well set-up to make it to the final tribal council. But, thanks to one erratic player, she found herself in a tie situation at the Final 4 which she could not fight her way out of and left the game on Day 37. Cydney gets a pass despite not actually being eliminated on Day 38 since she was still the last member of the jury.

Cydney’s game began on the Brawn tribe, where she quickly realized she needed to cozy up to the two muscleheads who were calling the shots, Kyle Jason and Scot Pollard. Just by keeping a low profile and cheesin’ whenever possible, she got to the merge pretty easily, by which time she was finally able to make some moves of her own. At the first vote after the merge, she noticed that Scot and Jason were getting chummy with former Beauty Nick Maiorano, which caused her to be like “brrr” and shake things up. She turned to two of her newest allies separately, Aubry Bracco and Michele Fitzgerald, who each had connections of their own, to amass enough votes to send Nick out of the game and planting Cydney firmly in the majority.

From that point forward, Cydney’s role in the overall narrative arc of the season diminished a bit, but it was still obvious to see what great of a game she was playing. The only people mad at her were Scot and Jason; everybody else viewed her as a trusted ally. She was in such a good position that she soon became a crucial swing when Jason was on his last legs, working to convince her and Michele to come over to his side, but Cydney stood her ground, wanting to remain loyal to her new allies.

Fast forward to the Final 4 and Cydney was in a great spot. She was much closer with both Aubry and Michele individually than those two were with each other, and knew that the two of them would target each other before they targeted her, and that’s exactly what happened. Michele won immunity, which meant Aubry was pretty much toast. But Aubry had something playing in her favor that nobody else had, and his name was Tai Trang. Tai had been an erratic player for the majority of the game and had followed Aubry’s lead the last couple of rounds. Those two factors led to Tai forcing a tie at the next tribal council, making Cydney compete in a fire-making tiebreaker challenge against Aubry.

Unfortunately for Cydney, she needed more heat than she could muster, as she lost the fire-making challenge and had her torch snuffed. While she didn’t get to Day 39, Cydney still played a really strong game without relying on a lot of big moves. Instead, she just relied on her cheerful, observant, hysterical personality to get far in the game while leaving a lasting impression on Survivor: Kaoh Rong.

KelleySnuff10. Kelley Wentworth (Survivor: Cambodia – Second Chance)

Not only was Kelley Wentworth an underdog to get to Day 38, but she was also an underdog to get onto this season in the first place. As one of the 32 names on the ballot to decide the cast of Survivor: Cambodia, Kelley seemed like a longshot to land a spot, considering she was just a pre-merge boot her first season. Through some aggressive campaigning, however, Kelley made the cut, making the trek to Cambodia ready to take advantage of her second chance. Throughout her 38 days, Kelley showed that she did indeed have the chops to play the game, and while she didn’t play perfectly, she more than made up for that in the sheer grit and determination she showed, living up to the underdog moniker that seemed to fit her so naturally.

Kelley, much like her fellow second chance competitors, hit the ground running as soon as she hit the beach, forming bonds left and right with anybody she could talk to, but she also engaged in some sneaky (sneaky) activities of her own. During the first three days, she discovered a clue to the hidden immunity idol, a clue that would force her to retrieve the first idol ever hidden within a challenge. Watching Kelley gauge the right moment to snag the idol, while in the midst of her entire tribe, was an exciting Survivor first to watch, and one that bore fruit for Kelley.

Having that idol, and not telling a soul about it, proved to be extremely valuable for Kelley later on. Although she had managed to avoid tribal council for most of the pre-merge, she was still in a tight spot come the merge and looked to be a goner come the Final 12 round. But when the majority alliance least expected it, she whipped out her idol and canceled all nine votes that were cast for her, setting a new Survivor record for votes nullified by an idol. That move sent a message to all of the other players that Underdog Wentworth was here to play.

After that small victory, Kelley was able to finagle her way into a couple of “voting blocs” for the next couple of rounds, but she still could never find her way into the majority. No matter how hard she tried, and she tried a lot, she could never find people that wanted to commit to her until the end due to her underdog momentum becoming too dangerous for the other players. It looked like her game would finally flame out at the Final 6, but, thanks to another hidden immunity idol, she managed to save herself yet again, causing the infamous “no votes” tribal council to take place.

After squeaking past that vote, she snagged an immunity victory at the Final 5 and was one challenge away from finishing one of the greatest underdog stories in Survivor history. But, she fell, and was unanimously voted out by the majority alliance. Although she didn’t win, Kelley’s journey this season proved that you could be a pre-merge boot in one season, and then come back and kick butt in another season and that you can always keep trying until your torch goes out.

MalcolmSnuff9. Malcolm Freberg (Survivor: Philippines)

Surfer-bro on the outside, nerdy superfan on the inside, Malcolm Freberg had a swagger that made playing Survivor look just plain cool. Whether it was flashing hidden immunity idols or hatching plans with his bros, Malcolm played with a passion befitting any superfan and showed that dreamy hunks with long hair could actually play Survivor well. Although he looked like a total package player at first, there were a couple of fundamental flaws that prevented Malcolm from reaching the end and landed him a spot in the Day 38 Club.

Malcolm’s story in Survivor: Philippines was one of the greatest “rags to riches” tales in Survivor history. He started off on the infamous Matsing tribe, one of the worst groups ever assembled in Survivor history. Matsing never managed to win a challenge against its two rival tribes and was ultimately whittled down to just Malcolm and his most trusted ally, Denise Stapley. After they had been split up, Malcolm spent the short time away from Denise adapting well to his new tribe, making allies left and right, which would come in handy when reunited with Denise at the merge.

Battle-tested from their time on Matsing, Malcolm and Denise were in a great spot, as the remnants of the two other tribes sought their votes in their war against each other. That cushy spot didn’t last for very long, though, when Malcolm’s threat level outgrew the charm he had been relying on previously. Luckily for him, he had a hidden immunity idol, and at the Final 10 tribal council, he was able to develop a signature move of sorts, perfecting the art of the idol bluff, daring anybody to come at him at the risk of their lives in the game.


Not only did it work, but Malcolm soon found himself in a solid Final 4 alliance with himself, Denise, Lisa Whelchel and Mike Skupin. During the final stretch of the game, he demonstrated what a true threat he was by balancing his charm and strategic skills by winning a couple of key challenges, pushing him all the way into the Final 4. Malcolm seemed set for the Final 3, despite being the biggest threat in the game. But when Denise came looking for some reassurance of going to the end together, Malcolm failed to reciprocate those same feelings. That one misread of the situation turned out to be his most crucial mistake, as Denise felt no more loyalty to Malcolm and sided with Lisa and Mike to send him out of the game on Day 38.

Throughout Survivor: Philippines, Malcolm played the game to its fullest extent, showing that more than just nerdy guys with glasses can call themselves superfans and embrace a love for the game. More than just his mactor-y appearance, Malcolm often acted like a dork himself, making Harry Potter references, and never took himself too seriously. His fun-loving attitude and penchant for shaking up the game have made Malcolm one of the faces of the new generation of Survivor players, setting the bar high for pulling off great Survivor moves with style.

< 14 – 12 8 – 6 >

Ian, from Chicago, Illinois, graduated with a Communications major and an English minor and is now navigating adult life the best he can. He has been a fan of Survivor since Pearl Islands aired when he was 11 years old, back when liking Rupert was actually cool.

  • Al

    Kelley is way too low. Should’ve been top 5 in my opinion.

  • Ishay

    Noo! Both Malcolm and wentworth deserved a higher place

  • Dennis

    This is ridiculously low for Wentworth and Malcolm, especially Kelley. I have no clue how anyone could rank her outside of Top 5 based on the game she played and overall story she had.

  • Žymantas

    It’s coming down to the wire, I get it, but all of these players should’ve been higher, especially Wentworth who had a huge shot at winning the game in addition to all the points you made – the idol finds, the underdog story, the strategic maneuvering of people not really alligned with her and the snarky confessionals.

  • Louie

    All three should be up at least one or two spots

  • Tommy

    All 3 should be Top 5

  • Yomomma

    lol Cydney actually had control over the game. Malcom & Kelley got a couple lucky idols and besides that had no control whatsoever, no sway or any power. Don’t know why people are whining about them not making it further when it should be Cydney. The bias is real with this one..

    • Ishay

      It’s only about control of the game, it’s about the character’s story arc

  • Red

    How are these 3 lower then Kass that is what shocks me.

    We are left with Kass, Fairplay, Ciere, Kathy, Rudy, Lex, Rob C, Yah.

    I am hoping Rob gets first

    • Name

      Kass was an entermainment beast in Cagayan. Loved seeing her both times. Also, I believe this list takes into account factors other than just than the strategic gameplay, such as story arcs and especially entertainment value, which would be more than enough to justify Kass topping Cydney in the list, who although a very likable player by the audience, was for most of the season a background character in the edit, emerging in the foreground at times but mostly taking a backseat to the more entertaining characters such as Aubry, Tai, and Jason.

  • Joseph

    Yeah, agree with mainly everyone, shocked Cydney and Kelley ranked where they are right now … then again I was a huge Cydney and Kelley fan so I may just be bias lol, but still, seems way too low.

  • Tom

    All of these people need to be higher. Fairplay and Rudy did not play better games then any of them. And the fact that just about every comment says Kass should be lower then them is telling.

    • Martin Holmes

      Ian didn’t base his ranking just on who played better games. It was a combo of game, character, story. 🙂

  • Daniel

    Yeah this list has lost some credibility due to the Wentworth and Malcolm placings. Wentworth convinced Keith to stay, and made her own fake idol.

    • Daniel

      Also I can’t believe the homophobic Rudy will be as high as this

  • Ben

    I feel like top 11 is the boss tier. Ranking them is tough. Every time I tried to do it my rankings would probably change.

    For right now, I think I’d say (combination of game, character, story to make it match the intent).

    1) Cirie
    2) Rob C
    3) Yau-Man
    4) Rudy
    5) Kelley
    6) Kathy
    7) Cydney
    8) Lex
    9) Malcolm
    10) Kass
    11) Fairplay

    But that was hard work.

  • Paul

    While it’s sad they’re out, I don’t think these three are badly placed. They’re in the top 10ish. Cydney and Malcolm was great, but lacked the story that some of the ones remaining had: Rudy, for obvious reasons. and Kathy V.O. as the first real growth arc last boot. I mean, that’s sort of the whole end game story of Marquesas. Kathy V.O. for the win.

  • John

    CYDNEY GILLON being ranked lower than Kelley McBland Wentworth is a travesty. Cyd controlled the game while Kelley got lucky with idols and lacked the character that Cydney had. Kelley is also an overrated strategist; she was not able to get numbers onto her side. Ciera orchestrated the Kelly blindside and got the ball rolling on the Stephen one and Joe was an obvious tribe decision. After that Kelley wasn’t in the majority at all.

  • Elyse

    Rip Cydney just robbed of top 10. In my opinion and this isn’t just recency bias she is ranked in at least top 5. Pulling for a Cirie win for once on anything

    • Paul

      Oops, I forgot about Cirie somehow when touting Kathy. I guess Cirie, in my mind, is just so naturally in her own robbed class. Plus, it’s still depressing to see how she was shafted in Micronesia, so I guess I don’t dwell on it much.

  • Radix

    My top 10, in no particular order, are Rudy, Kathy, Rob Cesternino, Jonny Fairplay, Ian, Yau-Man, Cirie, Malcolm, Kelley and Cydney. So, I’m quite content so far. 🙂
    Probably my top 6 out of them would be Rudy, Kathy, Rob C., JFP, Yau-Man and Cirie, so I’m looking forward for the next countdown.

  • John

    upset that Cydney was placed lower than Kelley McBland Wentworth who couldn’t get numbers on her side herself. Ciera/Stephen orchestrated the Kelly blindside, and Ciera orchestrated a Stephen blindside that was followed through the next tribal due to an idol. She is a boring character and overrated gameplayer so if this is a mixture of story arch and character and gameplay idk why Cydney is lower than her. Cydney actually had control and personality.