Survivor 51

Episode 9 Recap – Luck of the Irish

What went down in the latest episode?

CBS

With Kristin and Kilby knocked out of the game by Devin and Jelly’s minority split-vote plan, the duo dodged a unanimous vote and shook things up big time… assuming they aren’t just voted out next, now that they’ve made a couple of huge moves. But for now they’re doing their happy dances, as is Cristian, who thinks he made the biggest move of the season by pulling a random scroll out of a bag. Okay then.

Eric also hands Cristian his useless extra vote back to build trust and potentially use as a bluff down the line, so with that and Carter’s idol, this ride-or-die duo has real power now… until Cristian runs right to Sharonda and sells Carter out. Turns out Savu Strong is still very much a thing, and Carter is just being played, as is everyone else who thinks Sharonda’s vote for Devin and Jelly proves she isn’t working with them to the end.

The next morning, Maggie leads a hunt for any re-hidden idols, but Devious Devin is back to his villainous ways with a fake idol scheme. Built before the merge and packaged with Jelly’s idol parchments, he drops it along the path and waits for some poor sucker to take the bait. Meanwhile, Thien An and Lewis meet up and discuss the clear biggest threat left: Jelly. She’s played a better game than anyone believed until now, and players with lesser resumes should be hungry to take her down and claim that clout heading into a competitive endgame.

Up for grabs for reward this week is a helicopter tour of the islands and a fried chicken feast for the winning team of five, and all I have to say is thank you for remembering rewards can be cooler than whatever happened at the Sanctuary for the last five years, including the Zac Brown experience. Lewis singlehandedly slingshots himself, Mike, Devin, Thien An, and Eric into the winner’s circle. Between the merge feast, the spaghetti reward, and this feast, Lewis is eating like a king.

Meanwhile, the rest of the tribe is stuck at camp swatting away flies and hoping to swat Lewis over to the jury. He’s too good in challenges to keep around for too long, and the Helicopter Alliance plus Cristian is getting that ball rolling on a blindside. And Lewis does himself no favors when the reward group returns to camp in a chopper escort, and he goes off raving about the feast to a bunch of hungry losers. Jelly was already in a bad mood, and now she’s a straight-up hater (her words, not mine). The resident camp hater gets to work spinning a web around the new target by convincing Eric to turn against the very guy who won him that feast in the first place.

But the game of Survivor can swing from highs to lows overnight, and this night is a definitive low as a massive storm blows through camp. The game moves on, though, and Jelly is beginning to worry that Maggie might be the bigger threat to take out next. Lewis is good in challenges, sure, but Maggie is a social and strategic threat far above him on the hierarchy. She doesn’t even need to win immunities to be threatening, but her solid connections could make her a harder sell to the others. But any opportunity to weaken Maggie should be taken, and Devin jumps on his chance to lead her to his fake idol and get her super comfy with a new target on her back.

In a delightful and hilarious turn of events, Devin royally plays himself when Maggie doesn’t even see it, forces Devin to find it for her to keep his plan alive, and then refuses to even take it when he offers it to her on a silver platter. The fake idol he made is now his, as is any heat that might come from having it once people find out. And you know Maggie’s not letting that information stay between just them. So now this man’s own evil scheme has been turned against him, and Maggie proves she really doesn’t need anything but her social game and strategic senses to stay in a good spot as long as others keep tripping over themselves.

With immunity on the line in a battle of endurance, Carter outlasts comp beast Lewis to secure a top nine spot, and Lewis realizes he might’ve just screwed himself doing so well in yet another challenge, and arguably the one he’s needed to win the most so far with all the sharks circling. He did so well that the possible Maggie plan is on the back burner despite Jelly’s own personal feelings on the matter, and that group of Jelly, Devin, Sharonda, Mike, and Eric are locked in. Meanwhile, Carter brings up Lewis as a possible vote to Maggie, who’s more in favor of taking Jelly out, with Thien An agreeing. And then there’s Cristian, who has to worry about breaking Carter’s trust if they fall on opposite sides of this vote.

Lewis sees the writing on the wall: himself and Jelly are the only real targets, so he’s gotta get to work and whip out that Irish charm. Devin tells him straight up that unless he gets better options, he’s writing Lewis’ name down. Weaponized honesty backfired for Devin in the pre-merge many times. Despite his claim that it works to keep big players around who play on his level in the post-merge, it might backfire again when Lewis is energized to fight and pushes a Jelly vote with whatever numbers he can find, forcing a tie at best with the Salt Alliance hopefully on his side.

He keeps that energy going at Tribal as he bickers with Devin over what was actually said in their previous chat, but the conversation quickly shifts to million-dollar coin talk instead. A good number of players are excited to flip it when it eventually appears. Cristian’s already lucky, so why not press it further? Lewis needs immunity so bad and won’t turn it down, and Devin wants to be That Guy and carry on Rick Devens’ legacy even if it kills his game. And lo and behold, tonight is indeed the night. If the flipper calls it, they win immunity and an idol while doubling the prize. If it fails, the extra money carries over to the next season, and the flipper heads to the jury without a vote.

Somehow, the show milks this coin-flip talk for several minutes, with everyone debating whether it’s worth letting someone you’re not working with get an idol, and Cristian touching the thing to read its energy. It comes down to Devin and Lewis arguing over who flips it, taking their conflict to a standing debate when Lewis comes across as wishy-washy. Devin is passionate; Lewis is fearful. Risking it on a coin is, well, risky if Devin is willing to step up, but Lewis doesn’t want Devin and Jelly to get another idol if he calls it right. And fear is more of a driving force tonight with his back to the wall, so Lewis finally steps up to the mat and calls the fire side of the coin. Sadly for the Irishman, his luck has run dry, and the coin comes up water, dousing his dreams and his torch in one fell swoop.

So how does this twist stack up on its second edition? Well, the lack of Mr. Beast in the episode was a major improvement! Unfortunately, that’s about the nicest thing I can say. While I can’t say Lewis was actually robbed, as he was likely going home with or without the coin, not every coin flip round will be as cut and dry (assuming that tied vote red herring Lewis fed us was just that, a red herring). For every obvious boot who gets told to flip the coin with hardly any opposition (let’s be real, Devin only wanted to flip it for glory and you’ll rarely find someone that bold and crazy), there will be amazing, season-defining blindsides that get ruined because the coin flip made someone’s hard work pointless. Not to mention, if there’s no volunteer, the flipper is decided by rocks, so someone will be royally screwed over in the future if they keep this twist as a mainstay beyond the next successful flip.

For a mechanic that’s meant to add high stakes and drama to the show, it ultimately just sucks the wind out of any episode’s sails unless the episode was already a massive bore with no chance of an interesting ending. And sadly this isn’t the lesson production learned from its appearance in Season 50, where Jeff spent the whole Tribal glazing Mr. Beast and the coin flip for causing the crazy mess of the round instead of the messy players who made it all possible, assuming there was still going to be a normal vote in the first place.

Is the coin flip saving someone on the bottom and giving them new power in the game a fun shakeup? Sure. Won’t argue with that. But someone leaving with a sad whimper because they called the wrong side of the coin is even worse TV than a standard boring vote to me, and not just because you can spoil yourself by looking at how much time is left in the episode when they get up to flip it. At least a boring vote still had the potential to be interesting with the right conversations and pitches once in a while, and at worst, it’s a natural end to someone’s story. Plus, you don’t need to waste even more time at Tribal talking about coins when you can show more worthwhile camp scenes pre-challenge and then yadda-yadda a predictable ending like they did in the old days.

So yeah, once the coin flip is successful again and someone wins a record amount of money on the shoulders of Lewis and others who’ll fall along the way, nuke the twist from orbit or find a better way to include it if it’s not going anywhere. For example, why not just rework it to be less extreme? If you fail, you can’t compete in the next immunity challenge and lose your vote that night (a fair penalty but not a broken one), but a success still doubles the money and gets you immunity and, let’s say, an extra vote or vote steal instead of an idol. That way it’s something people in safer spots might actually want to flip by choice without risking everything if they want to grab power, and it doesn’t totally cancel potentially interesting votes by design.

Either way, I’m not looking forward to the dragged-out two-hour version of this episode next season that might end with the same resounding thud. Still, at least the next episode appears to be a return to form without any massive twist reheating Season 50’s already stale nachos. We have Maggie confronting Devin about the fake idol and letting out one of the longest screams in Survivor history, plus Thien An finally gets time to shine as the queen of the anti-Jelly movement after being sidelined for so long. Give me all of that over a janky coin flip any day.


Written by

Cory Gage

Cory is a writer and student from Texas. He's a die-hard Survivor fanatic who's seen over 50 seasons worldwide, hosted his own season in high school from scratch, and hopes to one day compete on the show himself.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


The reCAPTCHA verification period has expired. Please reload the page.