Survivor Second Chance Retrospective: Spencer Bledsoe


Age: 22
Hometown: Chicago, IL
Previous Season: Survivor: Cagayan
Previous Placing: 4th
Most Memorable Moment: Finding the hidden immunity idol during the mad idol hunt.

What happened in his previous season: Spencer went from a “0% chance of winning this game”, as stated by Jeff Probst pre-game, to reaching the Final 4, and becoming arguably the most popular player to come out of Cagayan.

He began his Cagayan journey on the dysfunctional Luzon tribe; probably one of the most ineffective tribes in Survivor history. After David and Garrett had been voted out, Spencer became the last man standing, and the next target. The girls, Kass and Tasha, kept him around due to his challenge prowess, and took out rice-spilling, crazy-pants J’Tia instead. When the tribe swap happened, Spencer ended up in a majority on the new Aparri tribe. He and his fellow Brains tribe members Kass and Tasha were in a position to control the vote.

Come the merge, Spencer was still in the majority, but after an insane Tribal Council where Kass switched her vote, cementing her moniker as #ChaosKass, Spencer was sent back to his underdog role in the minority alliance. His alliance was slowly dwindling, and he was always the next target. But his scrappy, determined gameplay allowed him to win 3 Individual Immunities and even uncover a Hidden Immunity Idol. He sided with the majority alliance to vote out LJ, Jefra, and Trish, but ultimately was voted out at the Final 4 due to being a huge jury threat.

He made a plea during his Final Tribal Council speech and stated that everyone should vote for Tony to win over Woo because Tony played in a way that honored the game of Survivor, whereas he saw Woo as Tony’s lap dog.

Spencer was a finalist for the Rob Has a Podcast Mr. Survivor 2015, and ultimately won the title.

What to expect from him this season: As with the other Cagayan contestants, Spencer is going into this season with a huge target on his back. With four Cagayan representatives taking up spots on the cast, regardless of whether they intend to work together or not, they will be perceived as a potential voting bloc. He’s also shown in his previous season that he thinks strategically, is a super fan that is knowledgeable about the game, and is a very competent challenge performer.

Spencer will not want to be an underdog again this season; he doesn’t want to be fighting from the back-foot, so expect to see him in a more dominant, controlling position if he is on a tribe with potential allies. His strong connection to the Survivor community means he is friendly with a lot of the fellow Second Chance cast members in real life. If he starts on a tribe with any of those people (the likes of Kelley, Peih-Gee, Shirin, Stephen, etc.) he has a chance to succeed. Should he end up on a tribe with lots of old schoolers and alpha males he may, unfortunately, find himself in that underdog position once again. Also, his Final Tribal Council speech was very negative towards Woo, and his love/hate relationship with Kass in Cagayan could lead to a very good chance of those two butting heads again.

Prediction: If he starts the game with the wrong mix of people he’s going to be targeted right out of the gate and end up a pre-merge casualty. But if he gets into a solid alliance quickly, and survives the early game, he can make it to the merge. Overall, Spencer will finish in a worse position than in Cagayan; Inside Survivor says early merge boot.

Thanks for reading our Second Chance Retrospective for Spencer Bledsoe.

What do you think Spencer’s chances are next season? Leave your comments below.

Rob is 30 years old from Boston, MA. He studied Architectural Engineering at college and has been following Survivor since the first season. He is married and has a dog named Snoopy. He also hosts Survivor ORGs (Online Reality Games) on Facebook.

  • Jeff

    I agree with your entire prediction. Early merge boot most likely. Although I’d like to see him get to something like 5th or 6th place.

  • Matheus

    I’m guessin’ early merge boot too, hoping he at least gets to the jury.

  • Courtenay-Leah

    So accurate!

  • Al Presser

    Loved Spencer in cagayan but he’s an early boot I see him having trouble relating to people. I think were gonna see the cocky kid that Jeff originally predicted

  • Gina

    I honestly don’t care when he gets booted, as long as kass rightfully outlasts him.

  • Ricardo

    While Spencer is a great player, he will probably need a lot of luck to make the merge. If he makes it, he’ll be out at first opportunity.
    Men VS Women would probably make him a pre-merge boot; old VS young could give him a chance to make the merge, but it would strongly depend on which people would want to work with him, giving his reputation. If the tribes are divided randomly.. well.. who knows? I even see scenario’s where Spencer would follow obvious first boot Kass out the door immediately.

  • Freckles

    I hope Joe can smoke this clown in challenges!
    He may have an ally in Tasha but together they’ll be seen as a threat, so early boot maybe pre-merge is my guess…

  • Leggy

    I want Spencer to go far, but unless his pre-game alliances work out, he’s toast.

    Everyone knows his story, and how tenacious he can be. They aren’t going to fall asleep and let him do his thing. I only hope he makes it farther than Kass this time.

  • yogi

    i would love to see spencer,joe and stephen forming an 3 men alliance that would be epic !!

  • laura

    I really hope spencer goes far he was my favorite in is season, and was one of my favorites over all.